Over 60 years ago, when more than half of Catholic clergy were still heterosexually oriented, if a man in priestly formation left the seminary, or if a priest left the priesthood, it ordinarily was to marry. The decline in heterosexuals entering seminaries, the closure of most high school seminaries, and the increase in priests leaving ministry were prompted, in great part, by the sexual revolution of the 1960s. To make up for the loss of straight seminarians and priests, Church leaders recruited more and more homosexuals who today make up the majority of Catholic bishops, priests, and seminarians outside of Africa, Eastern Europe, the Middle East, and parts of Asia like India.
Today, with so very few straight men in formation, the main reason for someone leaving the seminary is not to marry. The main reason heterosexual men voluntarily, or involuntarily, leave formation today is because of the homosexual cultures that exist in many seminaries in the Americas and Europe. Homosexual vocation directors who recruit other homosexuals, and homosexual seminary rectors who weed out heterosexuals who do not accept homosexual relationships and behavior, appear to have convinced lay Catholics that it doesn’t matter if a seminarian or priest is straight or gay, as long as he supposedly lives a celibate life. The truth is that there are many problems involved with that argument.
Unlike “chastity,” which means abstaining from sexual relations outside of marriage, “celibacy” technically means not being [heterosexually] married. It’s interesting how many gay priests do not believe they are violating their promise of celibacy by engaging in gay sex because, technically, they are not marrying their sex partner(s).
When a straight man is ordained and promises “celibacy” or vows “chastity,” he is not just foregoing having sex, but he is also sacrificing having a wife and children, which marriage is really all about. Because a gay seminarian is psychologically incapable of loving a woman and being “married” (as defined by the Catholic Church), promising celibacy, unlike vowing chastity, is like a person giving up smoking for Lent when he or she has never smoked.
Aware of how the careers of priests like Monsignor Jeffrey Burrill have been destroyed after they got caught using gay hook-up Apps like Grindr, most gay seminarians are advised to lead closeted lives and never reveal the fact that they are homosexually oriented, or that they may have been sexually active before or even during their time in the seminary.
Countless straight men have decided not to study for the priesthood or have left formation, not because they felt they could not lead celibate lives, but because they didn’t want to work for or with closeted gay clerics whose motives for being ordained they seriously questioned.
Because most studies and news reports about seminarians and newly ordained priests do not address the issue of sexual orientation, most people are unaware of how many straight men were unjustly dismissed for reporting sexual predation or homosexual misconduct in their seminaries.
Catholics who don’t object to the acceptance and ordination of homosexuals fail to realize: 1) The documented link between homosexual clergy and clerical sexual abuse; and 2) Just as straight men do not go to gay bars, so too have countless straight men voluntarily left formation after they discovered how the priesthood has evolved into a fraternal organization composed mainly of gay men, many of whom are sexually active and who do not view their sexual behavior as a violation of “celibacy.”
On Saturday, May 23, 2026, Bishop Joseph Brennan ordained Scott Vicent Borba, a homosexually oriented priest for the Diocese of Fresno. The media literally “canonized” Borba based on a somewhat materialistic interpretation of his transition from billionaire executive to parish priest. What both the mainstream and Catholic media avoided reporting was how he gave up living what he considered an unhealthy, unhappy lifestyle, and that he supports the official teaching of the Catholic Church on the immorality of homosexual behavior. Knowing how difficult it is for people who give up addictive behavior (smoking, drugs, alcohol, extramarital sex), I pray that he will be able to sustain his commitment to be a dedicated and holy priest.
This Substack column is free. If you find it informative, please recommend it to others and support it by contributing to the “Save Our Seminarians” Fund.
Gene Thomas Gomulka is a sexual abuse victims’ advocate, investigative reporter, and screenwriter. A former Navy (O6) Captain/Chaplain, seminary instructor, and diocesan Respect Life Director, Gomulka was ordained a priest for the Altoona-Johnstown diocese and later made a Prelate of Honor (Monsignor) by St. John Paul II. Email him at msgr.investigations@gmail.com.




Thanks very much, Fr Gene. Plainly a straight man is going to feel uncomfortable in a seminary with a large gay clique. As Fr David Marsden noted in 2018 after he had left Oscott seminary on the north east edge of the Birmingham urban sprawl.
https://www.corrispondenzaromana.it/international-news/an-open-letter-to-the-bishops-of-england-wales-and-scotland/
Needless to say, Oscott denied his account. But they did not sue. Under the appalling British libel laws they could easily have destroyed him. But too many embarrassing witnesses might have surfaced. And I suspect that Fr David had plenty of these witnesses up his sleeve. Any sane lawyer would have advised Oscott that they did not want Fr David's very specific and detailed allegations being repeated in the world wide media.
And any number of vocations have been destroyed long before they got near a seminary. What parent in my diocese is going to let their son anywhere near a seminary after seeing the priest ordained in my parish in 2007? Yes, "All are welcome" was the opening hymn. The new priest was so bent that he reminded me of the camp characters in the old "Carry on" films.
https://youtube.com/shorts/wUhN2X_pxEk?si=8K7ErbcIwo8ORCD8
Plainly only a small subset of "All" are going to be welcome in the modern church. Jesus told His disciples that He would make them fishers of men. But if you are fishing in a very small lake you are going to get very few vocations. And very few male converts who might be the backbone of future parishes and lay organisations.
So it is no surprise that parishes galore are being merged to accommodate the shrinking number of overworked priests. Next up: merge the moribund dioceses. Menevia (south west and central Wales) merged with Cardiff (south east Wales) in 2024. Three dioceses in north east England will likely merge soon.
Well, you then need fewer bishops whose backgrounds are 300% squeaky clean and who won't be destroyed by the first investigation. And seeing that you have a steadily shrinking talent pool of priests who are young enough, might make good bishops and are not compromised....
https://thepillar.substack.com/p/a-bishop-with-three-hats-stock-on?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=9bqtm
And that will probably be only the start.